My wife and I were flying home from Aruba and had a short connecting flight for the final leg of our trip. We were seated across the aisle from each other in aisle seats.
While boarding was still underway, my wife mentioned that she could hear audio from what she thought was my phone. I lowered my volume, but she said she could still hear it. After checking, I realized the sound was actually coming from a passenger seated by the window who was watching a movie without headphones.
After takeoff, my wife mentioned it to a flight attendant, but nothing happened immediately. A few minutes later, I politely got the passenger's attention and asked if he could turn the sound off or use headphones. He responded by asking whether it was really bothering me. I told him that it was and that audio on flights is generally expected to be listened to through headphones.
He seemed irritated but agreed, saying he had headphones in his bag. However, while we were waiting for him to retrieve them, he began making comments about the situation. Even after everyone sat back down, he continued talking, saying that I was putting negativity into the world and that it would come back to me many times over.
At that point, I stopped engaging, put my headphones on, and returned to watching my movie. Despite that, he continued trying to keep the conversation going. My wife eventually asked a flight attendant to step in and address the situation.
I felt like I made a reasonable and polite request, especially on a late-night flight, but the interaction escalated far more than expected. Was I out of line for asking him to use headphones?