For the 2025 to 2026 year, I qualified for Concierge Key with about 580k Loyalty Points. I was excited since there is no clearly defined criteria for it.
That said, my experience did not match what others often describe. I fly weekly for work, but I only had noticeable engagement from the Concierge Key team around 25 percent of the time. This included occasional gate meetups, messages after landing, or updates about delays.
Access to the Flagship Lounge was nice when connecting through DFW, but it became repetitive over time with limited food variety. It also was not always practical during short layovers.
I even shifted my international travel to American Airlines to stay loyal, despite less convenient routes, including trips where there were no direct options.
I ended the year with 678k Loyalty Points and fully expected to be renewed, but I was not. I did not receive any communication about it and had to call to find out.
During that call, I was offered a paid option to retain Concierge Key status. The options were $10,000, or one million miles, or a mix of $5,000 plus 500,000 miles.
For me, that felt unreasonable given the level of benefits I actually experienced, so I declined.
Boarding first was nice, but not worth that level of cost.
Just sharing an honest experience.
0